📚 Foster, Claire Keegan

⚠ Warning: Spoilers

Great story. Highly recommended. The ability to express so much in so few words is impressive. Each sentence carries weight.

When you pick up a book and read, you feel like you are doing something, you are working through it, putting in some effort. The book is just an inanimate object you’re acting on, you are consuming it. But there are a few exceptional books where the relationship flips, books that read themselves. You are just there sitting passively, the book holds your hands and won’t let go; the words whisper themselves gently, naturally; suddenly, you realize, you’ve reached the end—or, rather, the end has reached you. The book, the physical object, lets go of your hands, but the words, the emotions, remain.

This book manages to convey a lot of emotions without telling us, simply describing landscapes or physical objects or simple actions. We must infer what’s going on. But this inferring is completely natural, effortless — we’re almost surprised by the clarity with which we know what we’re being shown.

The story has two separate topics that work on separate planes. The first is the emotions of the girl, as she explores this uncharted place, and of the afflicted family that hosts her.

The second, very interesting, is the role of secrets and silence. Keegan doesn’t prescribe a cut-and-dried philosophy, just shows us that different people have different and complex relationships with secrets and silence. There are countless instances. In addition to the central secret, we hear Dan lying about the hay and things that would be nice, if they were true; there are no secrets in this house; these old mattresses, they weep; this is different, more like a secret recipe; she has been crying but she isn’t ashamed; Aye, black out of the dye-pot, you mean; Many’s the man lost much just because he missed a perfect opportunity to say nothing; I have learned enough, grown enough, to know that what happened is not something I need ever mention. There’s even a simple sequence of: “Did she tell you anything?”; I don’t know what to say; “What did she tell you?”.

The story is woven beautifully. I like the girl’s ambivalence, making her feelings towards her hosts somewhat vague until the very end. It also works great because when the grown-ups say things or act in ways we don’t understand (e.g., God forgive me but if I ever run into that woman again it will be too soon), we get the sense that something is going on, but, at the time, we don’t know for sure. I like how the secret—in a house where there are no secrets—is revealed. The moment when the hand appears to reach out gives me the chills! And the ending, the allegiance, is superb, with the girl taking Kinsella’s You don’t ever have to say anything policy.

Quotes